07-18-2025, 02:28 AM
When building a strong and flexible roster in MLB The Show 25, having reliable utility players can make a huge difference. These are the guys who step in when a starter’s out, cover multiple positions without skipping a beat, and give you options during long seasons or in tough Diamond Dynasty matchups. Whether you're grinding through Ranked Seasons or just looking for value picks, versatility can save your lineup in critical moments.
Here are 12 of the best utility players you should consider adding to your squad in MLB The Show 25.
1. Kiké Hernández
A long-time favorite for utility roles, Kiké brings solid defense across the board—from infield to outfield—and some pop at the plate. His defensive ratings and clutch factor make him a must-have bench asset.
2. Brandon Drury
Drury’s got legit power and can slot in at almost every infield position, including first and third. He’s a smart addition if you’re looking to round out your roster without sacrificing bat speed or glove work.
3. Chris Taylor
Taylor continues to be one of the game’s most reliable Swiss Army knives. His ability to handle both middle infield and outfield duties makes him a strong pick for anyone aiming for flexibility.
4. Whit Merrifield
While he’s no longer elite in terms of speed, Merrifield still offers contact hitting and multi-positional defense. He’s a great option for players who value consistent at-bats and coverage.
5. Jeff McNeil
McNeil brings high contact ratings and can play second, third, and corner outfield spots. He’s an excellent fit for teams that prioritize batting average and disciplined plate appearances.
6. Isaac Paredes
Paredes has quietly built a reputation for sneaky power and positional flexibility on the corners. He’s especially useful in pinch-hit scenarios when you’re running low on bench bats.
7. J.D. Davis
Though his defense is average at best, Davis offers solid offensive value and can fill in at first, third, and occasionally left field. If you need a bat-first utility option, he’s your guy.
8. Tommy Edman
Edman’s speed and elite defense across multiple positions make him a perfect bench weapon. He’s capable of turning games around with baserunning alone, especially in tight spots.
9. Luis Rengifo
Rengifo is an underrated gem who can do a bit of everything—hit for contact, play five positions, and come up big in clutch moments. He’s especially valuable in Battle Royale or Events.
10. Jonathan India
India might be more known for his work at second base, but he can hold his own at third and left field too. His bat makes him playable almost anywhere.
11. Ben Zobrist (Legends Card)
If you manage to unlock or buy MLB The Show 25 Stubs to grab a Legends version of Zobrist, you’ll get one of the most versatile players in the game’s history. He can literally play everywhere except catcher and pitcher, and his all-around stats are top tier.
12. DJ LeMahieu
LeMahieu has aged gracefully in The Show, still offering excellent contact hitting and dependable defense at three infield spots. He's great for players who want to control the tempo of a game with smart, strategic at-bats.
When managing your team in Diamond Dynasty or Franchise mode, it’s easy to get caught up in star players and big bats. But utility players are often the unsung heroes, keeping your squad competitive and covered. If you're tight on budget or looking for depth, consider using MLB The Show 25 Stubs wisely to secure one or two of these names.
Platforms like U4N can be part of the conversation when sourcing what you need, especially when you're focused on building a well-rounded team without grinding endlessly.
Versatility isn’t flashy—but it wins games. Keep that in mind next time you’re tweaking your roster or searching for value pickups in MLB The Show 25.
Here are 12 of the best utility players you should consider adding to your squad in MLB The Show 25.
1. Kiké Hernández
A long-time favorite for utility roles, Kiké brings solid defense across the board—from infield to outfield—and some pop at the plate. His defensive ratings and clutch factor make him a must-have bench asset.
2. Brandon Drury
Drury’s got legit power and can slot in at almost every infield position, including first and third. He’s a smart addition if you’re looking to round out your roster without sacrificing bat speed or glove work.
3. Chris Taylor
Taylor continues to be one of the game’s most reliable Swiss Army knives. His ability to handle both middle infield and outfield duties makes him a strong pick for anyone aiming for flexibility.
4. Whit Merrifield
While he’s no longer elite in terms of speed, Merrifield still offers contact hitting and multi-positional defense. He’s a great option for players who value consistent at-bats and coverage.
5. Jeff McNeil
McNeil brings high contact ratings and can play second, third, and corner outfield spots. He’s an excellent fit for teams that prioritize batting average and disciplined plate appearances.
6. Isaac Paredes
Paredes has quietly built a reputation for sneaky power and positional flexibility on the corners. He’s especially useful in pinch-hit scenarios when you’re running low on bench bats.
7. J.D. Davis
Though his defense is average at best, Davis offers solid offensive value and can fill in at first, third, and occasionally left field. If you need a bat-first utility option, he’s your guy.
8. Tommy Edman
Edman’s speed and elite defense across multiple positions make him a perfect bench weapon. He’s capable of turning games around with baserunning alone, especially in tight spots.
9. Luis Rengifo
Rengifo is an underrated gem who can do a bit of everything—hit for contact, play five positions, and come up big in clutch moments. He’s especially valuable in Battle Royale or Events.
10. Jonathan India
India might be more known for his work at second base, but he can hold his own at third and left field too. His bat makes him playable almost anywhere.
11. Ben Zobrist (Legends Card)
If you manage to unlock or buy MLB The Show 25 Stubs to grab a Legends version of Zobrist, you’ll get one of the most versatile players in the game’s history. He can literally play everywhere except catcher and pitcher, and his all-around stats are top tier.
12. DJ LeMahieu
LeMahieu has aged gracefully in The Show, still offering excellent contact hitting and dependable defense at three infield spots. He's great for players who want to control the tempo of a game with smart, strategic at-bats.
When managing your team in Diamond Dynasty or Franchise mode, it’s easy to get caught up in star players and big bats. But utility players are often the unsung heroes, keeping your squad competitive and covered. If you're tight on budget or looking for depth, consider using MLB The Show 25 Stubs wisely to secure one or two of these names.
Platforms like U4N can be part of the conversation when sourcing what you need, especially when you're focused on building a well-rounded team without grinding endlessly.
Versatility isn’t flashy—but it wins games. Keep that in mind next time you’re tweaking your roster or searching for value pickups in MLB The Show 25.